Investigating India's Progress Toward Digital Authoritarianism

Evidence from Internet Shutdown Amidst Farmer Protest 2024

Authors

  • Dias Pabyantara Swandita Mahayasa Universitas Jenderal Soedirman Purwokerto
  • Muhammad Nur Alauddin Malik Universitas Jenderal Soedirman Purwokerto
  • Dinar Danahari Amalia Universitas Jenderal Soedirman Purwokerto

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15642/sarpass.2024.4.1.83-108

Keywords:

India, Digital Authoritarianism, Farmer Protest 2024, Minority

Abstract

The notion of economic development often goes hand in hand with political stability. Even in the so-called democratic countries, political stability usually came before democratic value as an underlying reason to keep economic development on track. As one of the biggest democratic countries, India also experiences the paradox. Paradoxically, being one of the digital superpowers with the highest total internet transactions and internet infrastructure, India consistently shown internet shutdowns amidst massive civil protests. Recently, there was a massive farmer protest in February 2024 towards minimum selling prices, which triggered the Indian government to cut off internet access and ban the platform 'X' in several districts in India. Using digital authoritarianism approaches, we argue that the Indian government has claimed digital sovereignty to construct counter-narratives toward the protesters. The strategy was to quell the agitation of the protesters and facilitate the filtering of information amidst massive protests. To investigate the notions, we performed qualitative content analysis upon official social media account of the Indian government. Further, they also target minority groups to limit freedom of information. The Indian government employed such tactics to cover up the atrocities that occurred to prevent attention from the international media. Thus, India does not receive allegations regarding human rights violations

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

@abhishekdeoraj. (2024, June 10). This needs to be realised by everyone and support the govt to continue with the good work. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/abhishekdeoraj/status/1800053069507641691

Accessnow. (2024, May 15). India leads the world internet shutdown count for sixth year - Access Now. AccessNow. Retrieved August 22, 2024, from https://www.accessnow.org/press-release/india-keepiton-internet-shutdowns-2023-en/

Agrawal, A. (2024, February 20). Amid farm protest, IT ministry blocks 177 accounts, links. Hindustan Times. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/amid-farm-protest-it-ministry-blocks-177-accounts-links-101708366564358.html

Al Jazeera. (2024, February 22). India's demand to block accounts amid farmers' stir curtails free speech: X. Al Jazeera. Retrieved September 29, 2024, from https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/2/22/indias-demand-to-block-accounts-amid-farmers-stir-curtails-free-speech-x

@ANI. (2024, February 21). After the fourth round, the government is ready to discuss all the issues like MSP, crop diversification, stubble issue, FIR in the fifth round. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/ANI/status/1760186481644015753

@AnilJha58772137. (2024, September 30). Farmers are demanding genuine rights not any luxuries. Government should fulfill their promise and legalize MSP, wave of farmers loans and withdraw fake cases against farmers. X.com. https://x.com/AnilJha58772137/status/1840575585745043940

Barma, N., Durbin, B., & Taylor, A. (2020, February). Digital Authoritarianism: Finding Our Way Out of the Darkness. War on The Rocks. Retrieved 2024, from https://warontherocks.com/2020/02/digital-authoritarianism-finding-our-way-out-of-the-darkness/

BBC. (2019, August 5). Article 370: What happened with Kashmir and why it matters. BBC. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-49234708

BBC. (2024, February 13). Why India farmers are protesting again. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-68282270

BBC. (2024, April 30). India's economy: The good, bad and ugly in six charts. BBC. Retrieved September 21, 2024, from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-68823827

Bhattacharya, A. (2024, September 27). India shuts down the internet far more than any other country. Rest of World. https://restofworld.org/2024/india-internet-shutdown-record/

Bystander Apathy and Intervention in the Era of Social Media. (2021). In The Emerald International Handbook of Technology-Facilitated Violence and Abuse (pp. 712-728). Emerald Publishing Limited.

Chaudhuri, D. (2024, February 25). Is legal assurance of MSP for farmers viable? What are its implications? Down To Earth. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://www.downtoearth.org.in/agriculture/is-legal-assurance-of-msp-for-farmers-viable-what-are-its-implications--94647

Chhabra, A., & Sebastian, M. (2024, February 14). Delhi: Farmers face tear gas trying to resume march to India capital. BBC. Retrieved September 15, 2024, from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-68271364

Dayal, S., Rajesh, Y., & Cawthorne, A. (2024, March 14). Why are farmers protesting in India? Reuters. Retrieved September 21, 2024, from https://www.reuters.com/world/india/why-farmers-are-protesting-new-delhi-2024-03-14/

Denzin, N. K., Lincoln, Y. S., Giardina, M. D., & Cannella, G. S. (Eds.). (2024). The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research. SAGE.

@FarmersFront. (2024, February 12). We condemn this action by @BJP4India party. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/FarmersFront/status/1756911897105023019

Funk, A., Shahbaz, A., & Vesteinsson, K. (2023). The Repressive Power of Artificial Intelligence. Freedom House. Retrieved August 27, 2024, from https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2023/repressive-power-artificial-intelligence#generative-ai-supercharges-disinformation

@GlobalAffairs. (2024, 2 21). The Indian government has issued executive orders requiring X to act on specific accounts and posts, subject to potential penalties including significant fines and imprisonment. X.com. Retrieved 8 29, 2024, from https://x.com/GlobalAffairs/status/1760387644608192560

Gunitsky, S. (2020, February 19). The Great Online Convergence: Digital Authoritarianism Comes to Democracies. War on the Rocks. Retrieved August 27, 2024, from https://warontherocks.com/2020/02/the-great-online-convergence-digital-authoritarianism-comes-to-democracies/

Henry, N. (2024, February 22). India farmers' protest: X admits to taking down posts and accounts. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-68366859

Human Rights Watch. (2024, February 29). India: Protect Farmers' Right to Peaceful Protest. Human Rights Watch. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/02/29/india-protect-farmers-right-peaceful-protest

Human Right Watch. (2023, June 14). “No Internet Means No Work, No Pay, No Food”: Internet Shutdowns Deny Access to Basic Rights in “Digital India” | HRW. Human Rights Watch. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://www.hrw.org/report/2023/06/14/no-internet-means-no-work-no-pay-no-food/internet-shutdowns-deny-access-basic

Inamdar, N. (2024, April 30). India's economy: The good, bad and ugly in six charts. BBC. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-68823827

@Jairam_Ramesh. (2024, February 14). वे आंदोलन कर रहे अन्नदाताओं के ख़िलाफ़ अपमानजनक बातें कर रहे हैं. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/Jairam_Ramesh/status/1757805044723036484

@Jairam_Ramesh. (2024, May 9). भारतीय राष्ट्रीय कांग्रेस ने करोड़ों किसानों की आवाज़ और कई किसान संगठनों की मांगों को सुना है। हमने खेती की व्यापक लागत का डेढ़ गुना MSP सुनिश्चित करने के लिए संसद से कानून पारित करने की गारंटी दी है।. X.com. https://x.com/Jairam_Ramesh/status/1788513688582066452

@KanchanGupta. (2024, February 14). ‘Farmers protest’ has disrupted their livelihoods. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/KanchanGupta/status/1757791887858020378

@KanchanGupta. (2024, June 10). PM Modi signed his first file authorising release of the 17th instalment of PM Kisan Nidhi. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/KanchanGupta/status/1800048371048067453

Kumar, R. (2024, February 15). Farmers protest: Third round of talks underway; internet shutdown extended in 7 Haryana districts. Hindustan Times. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/farmers-protest-third-round-of-talks-underway-internet-shutdown-extended-in-7-haryana-districts-101708007959235.html

Lahiri, J. (2024, February 22). Farmers protest: X complies with Indian government's order to suspend accounts but says "We disagree..." The Economic Times. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/x-complies-with-indian-governments-order-to-suspend-accounts-but-says-we-disagree-/articleshow/107896858.cms?from=mdr

Livingston, S., & Eachus, T. (1995). Humanitarian crises and U.S. foreign policy: Somalia and the CNN effect reconsidered. Political Communication, 12(4), 413-429.

@ManikGoyal_. (20224, February 22). Coward Modi is turning India into Autocracy ..... He can't even handle protest tweets. X.com. https://x.com/ManikGoyal_/status/1760526879994294451

@ManjeetChanna2. (2024, February 11). मोडानी सरकार ने किसानों को दुश्मन समझ कर सड़कों लोहे की किलो का इस्तेमाल कर ताकि किसान दिल्ली पहुंच ना पाए प्रधानमंत्री एक ट्रस्टी चुना हुआ जनता द्वारा,ये अशोभनीय व्यवहार लोकतंत्र में मोदी सरकार संविधान,लोकतंत्र के विरुद्ध किसानों की आवाज को कुचलने जा र. X.com. https://x.com/ManjeetChanna2/status/1756633720231194846

@mannraman1974. (2024). सरकार अपना MSP गारंटी कानून का वादा पूरा नहीं करेगी ! सरकार किसानों को दिल्ली नहीं आने देगी, ड्रोन से आंसू गैस फैंकेंगी, गोली चलाएगी, किसानों को शहीद करेगी !! लेकिन MSP गारन्टी कानून मांगने वाले किसानों पर फ़र्ज़ी मुक़दमे डाल कर, उन्हें जेल में जरूर डाल. X.com. https://x.com/mannraman1974/status/1778054643471266213

@mannraman1974. (2024, April 10). सरकार अपना MSP गारंटी कानून का वादा पूरा नहीं करेगी. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/mannraman1974/status/1778054643471266213

Minority Rights Group. (n.d.). Sikhs in India. Minority Rights Group. Retrieved September 21, 2024, from https://minorityrights.org/communities/sikhs/

Mishra, B. (2023, May 21). SC suggests no minimum support price for farmers burning stubble. www.business-standard.com. https://www.business-standard.com/economy/news/sc-suggests-excluding-farmers-burning-stubble-from-msp-structure-123112100954_1.html

Mitchell, R. (2024, April 1). Tracking Internet Shutdowns in 2024, Q1. Internet Society Pulse. Retrieved August 27, 2024, from https://pulse.internetsociety.org/blog/tracking-internet-shutdowns-in-2024-q1

Mitra, E., & Hollingsworth, J. (2021, February 1). India cuts internet around New Delhi as protesting farmers clash with police. CNN. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://edition.cnn.com/2021/02/01/asia/india-internet-cut-farmers-intl-hnk/index.html

Mittal, S. (2024, February 24). 'Govt allergic to facts': Journalists, farmer leaders enraged after X accounts withheld. Newslaundry. Retrieved September 15, 2024, from https://www.newslaundry.com/2024/02/24/govt-allergic-to-facts-journalists-farmer-leaders-enraged-after-x-accounts-withheld

@moliticsindia. (2024, Maret 6). किसानों पर सैन्य हथियारों का इस्तेमाल किया गया, इसमें कई किसानों की जान गई, 250 से अधिक घायल हैं।. X.com. https://x.com/moliticsindia/status/1765259468852600951

@mr_mayank. (2024, February 13). BIG BREAKING: "This is a black day in Indian history. Tear gases, rubber bullets & water cannons were used against the farmers today. We will continue our protest with double intensity tomorrow." — Farmer Leader Sarwan Singh Pandher. X.com. https://x.com/mr_mayank/status/1757417821112520992

@MundaArjun. (2024, February 21). मैं दोबारा किसान नेताओं को चर्चा के लिए आमंत्रित करता हूँ। हमें शांति बनाये रखना जरूरी है।. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/MundaArjun/status/1760178127685538031

NANU, N. (2024, February 14). India: Right to peaceful protest under threat due to mounting restrictions and escalating crackdown on farmers' march. Amnesty International. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/02/india-right-to-peaceful-protest-under-threat-due-to-mounting-restrictions-and-escalating-crackdown-on-farmers-march/

@Post4Lamba. (2024, February 22). Dictatorship ! No courage can exist in tyranny. This time, there will be an end to the excess. X.com. https://x.com/Post4Lamba/status/1760585229264142798

Pradhan, B. (2024, February 27). The Economics Behind India's Farmers Protest – The Diplomat. The Diplomat. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://thediplomat.com/2024/02/the-economics-behind-indias-farmers-protest/

@praveendel. (2024, February 20). जिस तरह सरकार उनके हित के लिए प्रयासरत है, उनको भी ये प्रयास करना होगा कि देश की अर्थव्यव्स्था पर अतिरिक्त बोझ ना पड़े।. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/praveendel/status/1759911301147488411

Pulse Internet Society. (2024). Global Internet Shutdowns. pulse.internetsociety.org. Retrieved 9 25, 2024, from https://pulse.internetsociety.org/shutdowns?search=in

Purohit, K. (2024, June 7). Did India's farmers ditch Modi's BJP in the 2024 election? Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/6/7/did-indias-farmers-ditch-modis-bjp-in-the-2024-election

@RahulGandhi. (2024, February 14). ‘सरकारी एक्सपर्ट्स’ को बजट की चिंता सताने लगती है, पर बात बजट की नहीं, नीयत की है।. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/RahulGandhi/status/1757771318437495223

Sadler, N. (2017, 9 20). Narrative and interpretation on Twitter: Reading tweets by telling stories. New Media & Society, 3266–3282.

Sinha, S. (2021, August). ‘Strong leaders’, authoritarian populism and Indian developmentalism: The Modi moment in historical context. Geoforum, 124, 320-333. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2021.02.019

@SupriyaShrinate. (2024, March 14). जहां किसान न्याय की प्रमुखता से बात हुई। किसानों को हमारी गारंटी है. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/SupriyaShrinate/status/1768159201631543743

@suryakantvsnl. (2024, February 19). केंद्र सरकार चार और फसलों पर MSP देने को तैयार, किसानों को मसूर, उड़द, मक्की व कपास उत्पादन के लिए नैफेड और सीसीआई से पांच साल का करार करना होगा।. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/suryakantvsnl/status/1759399633590063289

@suryapsingh_IAS. (2024, February 24). असली किसानों को ये बात समझने की ज़रूरत है, उपद्रवियों को तो आंदोलन करना ही है, क्यों कि उनका उद्देश्य तो कुछ और ही है।. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/suryapsingh_IAS/status/1761259515251454044

Times of India. (2023, June 12). India tops world ranking in digital payments, beats China by huge margin: Report. Times of India. Retrieved August 29, 2024, from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/gadgets-news/india-tops-world-ranking-in-digital-payments-beats-china-by-huge-margin-report/articleshow/100944643.cms

@tractor2twitr_c. (2024, February 24). It's been 3 days since farmer protester Shubhkaran Singh was shot dead. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/tractor2twitr_c/status/1761283831594971343

@Tractor2twitr_P. (2024, September 27). Farmers have been clear: they need #MSP guarantees, a concrete roadmap with financial clarity, and immediate action—not vague proposals or missed details. X.com. Retrieved 2024, from https://x.com/Tractor2twitr_P/status/1839676192787509468

Varshney, A., & Staggs, C. (2024, January). Hindu Nationalism and the New Jim Crow. Journal of Democracy, 35(1), 5-18. 10.1353/jod.2024.a915345

Venkatesh, A. (2024, May 17). Modi's anti-Muslim rhetoric taps into Hindu replacement fears that trace back to colonial India. The Conversation. Retrieved September 30, 2024, from https://theconversation.com/modis-anti-muslim-rhetoric-taps-into-hindu-replacement-fears-that-trace-back-to-colonial-india-229570

Williams, T., & Shepherd, D. (2017). Mix Method Social Network Analysis: Combining Inductive Concept Development, Content Analysis, and Secondary Data for Quantitative Analysis. Organizational Research Method, 268-298.

Yilmaz, I., & Saleem, R. A. (2024, December 8). Hindutva civilizational populist BJP’s enforcement of digital authoritarianism in India. Populism & Politics, (17), 5-6. https://doi.org/10.55271/pp0017

Downloads

Published

2024-11-30

How to Cite

Mahayasa, D. P. S., Malik, M. N. A., & Amalia, D. D. (2024). Investigating India’s Progress Toward Digital Authoritarianism: Evidence from Internet Shutdown Amidst Farmer Protest 2024. The Sunan Ampel Review of Political and Social Sciences, 4(1), 83–108. https://doi.org/10.15642/sarpass.2024.4.1.83-108

Issue

Section

Articles